Just came upon this article today, in my usual waiting-for-my-brain-to-wake-up rounds of sites likely to provide short articles that I will find moderately interesting: http://www.salon.com/2012/06/13/make_kids_memorize_poetry/
It starts off by reporting the negative reaction of progressives to a new proposal by Michael Gove, Britain's Education Secretary, to have schoolkids memorize poetry. I can sort of understand why people would be against it -- if one believes it's a step in turning all education into rote memorization, then it might seem really dangerous and creativity-killing. The article goes on to mention memory-building benefits to memorizing poetry. It also interviews a progressive who is home-schooling her kids with poetry memorization as part of the program, who says her kids seem to enjoy it. I can certainly believe that. Hanging out with my two young nephews (currently 4 and 5) is that the more they hear something the better they like it. Up to a point, of course, eventually the thing becomes to simple for them and they move on. But that comes waaay later than the memorization point. At two and a half, my nephew could sit at the dinner table and recite all of Where the Wild Things Are (with maybe a little help from my brother -- my brother now knows at least forty different kids' books entirely by heart, and can do scene-by-scene recounting of Charlie and the Chocolate Factory, including many of the lines). All of this is to say, I would expect that with the right poems and the right playful attitude, a great many kids (though not all) would enjoy memorizing poetry.
Last summer I started memorizing The Waste Land. I haven't looked at it much recently. I have about 240 lines down, which is a bit more than halfway. I keep meaning to get back to it but doing a PhD and living in two countries and all that other not-fun everyday stuff has gotten in the way a bit, but also I guess just that I'm nt good at being consistent at anything, even if I enjoy doing it. Other than watching television -- I've been incredibly consistent at devoting time to that, which I am currently trying (again) to change. The thing I felt about memorizing, though, was that it brought so much more to the language. I've recently started to think that poetry reading is harder for people whose thinking style tends towards quickness -- it takes an effort for me to slow my mind down enough to appreciate the words individually, which is where poetry comes to life. I can do it, and then it's amazing, but I have to consciously remind myself to. I have a sense that for other people that comes more naturally (I would like to know if this is true; maybe they simply have better training? Maybe it's some other difference entirely? I am also of an analytical bent, which can get in the way of some activities). But memorizing illuminates the words in a way that no slowness or concentration of reading could. I feel the connections between lines that are far from each other, and not just the obvious ones where the line is being repeated with a twist, but subtler things. Not that it's taking me to any great intellectual level, but it's incredibly enjoyable to see and feel the poem in that way. I can also imagine never getting tired of those words, which is great. It gives me something to do on walks on when standing in line. I guess the trouble is, when a huge institution brings it into its curriculum, it's likely to fuck it up and make it seem like an awful irrelevant chore. The experience of one intellectual and free-thinking mum with her two kids is likely to be quite different than that of a bunch of harassed, underpaid and possibly not entirely poetry-loving teachers with their sea of students.
We used to memorize poetry in English class from very early on until College. It was always a bit daunting ("what if I can't do it?!?!) but left me feeling accomplished and as you said, more connected to the writing.
ReplyDeleteI memorized some John Donne on my own a few years ago, simply because it was lyrical and easier for me to memorize than some other poetry. Also because it made me feel fancy, so there's that.
We are forced to memorize so much in school anyway, so you can't really argue against it. Well you CAN, but you'd be a giant douche canoe.
Also, can I say YAY that you're writing again? YAY!
ALSO: Kids are always memorizing song lyrics, which aren't so different than poetry. If your daughter can sing Hit Me Baby One More Time, then surely there's some room for Anne Sexton.
ReplyDeleteOh, and if it says anything about my ability in this area, I always end up singing my own lyrics to songs I've heard a million times. That said, I have superhuman memory as far as recalling events, so maybe it is a different kind of memory. A kind that taunts me mercilessly when I am pretending to be Lady Gaga.
Good point about song lyrics. Could putting the poetry to music be a useful method for kids to memorize? In choir a thousand years ago we sang a song in which the words were from a poem by Hillaire Belloc called The Yak, and I still remember a bunch of the words.
ReplyDeleteThanks for the encouragement! I am going to try to post much more this summer.
Btw you would make a great Lady Gaga. I can picture you in the outfits.
The Yak
ReplyDeleteBy Hilaire Belloc
As a friend to the children commend me the Yak.
You will find it exactly the thing:
It will carry and fetch, you can ride on its back,
Or lead it about with a string.
The Tartar who dwells on the plains of Thibet
(A desolate region of snow)
Has for centuries made it a nursery pet,
And surely the Tartar should know!
Then tell your papa where the Yak can be got,
And if he is awfully rich
He will buy you the creature—or else he will not.
(I cannot be positive which.)
Can you canoe in Kalamazoo?
ReplyDeleteCan you canoe in Kamloops?
Can you canoe at a quarter to two
in a van when the traffic jam-loops?
I can canoie in Kalamazoo
and I can canoe in Kamloops
But I cannot canoe at a quarter to two
in a van when the traffic jam-loops
Canoe?
(Dennis Lee)
Can you tell me what this is from? My kid is singing it and we’re stuck.
Delete